867-5309 (Penny) is the 23rd episode of The Penelope Show.


Penelope attempts to ruin Garfield's date with Arlene after hearing he'll propose to her that night. Meanwhile, Jon gets a new girlfriend, Jenny Clifton, in the weirdest way possible... a prank call.


  • It's revealed that Vito's phone number is 867-5308, one number off from 867-5309
    • It's also revealed Jon prank calls him often


  • The episode's name is a pun on the song "867-5309 (Jenny)" by Tommy Tutone
    • The reason is because that's the number Jon called it to prank call Jenny, meaning that it's her phone number, and also "Penny" is short for Penelope.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.